Monday, July 30, 2007

[wvns] Eric Margolis: Will US Attack Pakistan?

Is The US Preparing To Attack Pakistan?
By Eric Margolis
The Sun, Canada

The Bush Administration may be preparing to lash out at old ally
Pakistan, which Washington now blames for its humiliating failures to
crush al-Qaida, capture its elusive leaders, or defeat Taliban
resistance forces in Afghanistan.

One is immediately reminded of the Vietnam War when the Pentagon,
unable to defeat North Vietnamese Army and Viet Cong forces, urged
invasion of Cambodia.

Sources in Washington say the Pentagon is drawing up plans to attack
Pakistan's "autonomous" tribal region bordering Afghanistan. Limited
"hot pursuit" ground incursions by US forces based in Afghanistan,
intensive air attacks, and special forces raids into Pakistan's
autonomous tribal region are being evaluated.

This weekend, the US national intelligence chief and other
intelligence spokesmen confirmed that strikes against "terrorist
targets" in Pakistan's tribal belt are increasingly possible. These
warnings were designed to both further pressure Pakistan's beleaguered
strongman, President Pervez Musharraf into sending more troops to the
tribal areas to fight his own people, and to prepare US public opinion
for a possible widening of the Afghanistan war into Pakistan.

Pakistan's 27,200 sq km tribal belt, officially known as the Federal
Autonomous Tribal Area, or FATA, is home to 3.3 million Pashtun
tribesmen. It has become a safe haven for al-Qaida, Taliban, other
Afghan resistance groups, and a hotbed of anti-American activity,
thanks mostly to the US-led occupation of Afghanistan which drove many
militants across the border into Pakistan. Osama bin Laden is very
likely sheltered in this region, as US intelligence claims.

I spent a remarkable time in this wild, medieval region during the
1980's and 90's, traveling alone where even Pakistani government
officials dared not go, visiting the tribes of Waziristan, Orakzai,
Khyber, Chitral, and Kurram, and meeting their chiefs, called "maliks."

These tribal belts are always referred to as "lawless." Pashtun
tribesmen could shoot you if they didn't like your looks. Rudyard
Kipling warned British Imperial soldiers over a century ago, when
fighting cruel, ferocious Pashtun warriors of the Afridi clan, if they
fell wounded, "save your last bullet for yourself."

But there is law: the traditional Pashtun tribal code, Pashtunwali,
that strictly governs behavior and personal honor. Protecting guests
was sacred. I was captivated by this majestic mountain region and
wrote of it extensively in my book, "War at the Top of the World."

The 40 million Pashtun – called "Pathan" by the British – are the
world's largest tribal group. Imperial Britain divided them by an
artificial border, the Durand Line, which went on to become, like so
many other British colonial boundaries, today's Afghanistan-Pakistan
border. When Pakistan was created in 1947, the Pashtun were split
between that new nation and Afghanistan.

Pakistan's Pashtun number 28–30 million, plus an additional 2.5
million refugees from Afghanistan. Pashtuns, one of the British Indian
Army's famed "martial races," occupy many senior positions in
Pakistan's military, intelligence service and bureaucracy, and
naturally have much sympathy for their embattled tribal cousins in
Afghanistan. The 15 million Pashtun of Afghanistan form that nation's
largest ethnic group and just under half the population.

The tribal agency's Pashtun reluctantly joined newly-created Pakistan
in 1947 under express constitutional guarantee of total autonomy and a
ban on Pakistani troops ever entering there.

But under intense US pressure, President Pervez Musharraf violated
Pakistan's constitution by sending 80,000 federal troops to fight the
region's tribes, killing 3,000 of them. In best British imperial
tradition, Washington pays Musharraf $100 million monthly to rent his
sepoys (native soldiers) to fight Pashtun tribesmen. As a result,
Pakistan is fast edging towards civil war, as the bloody siege of
Islamabad's Red Mosque and a current wave of bombings across the
nation show.

The anti-Communist Taliban movement is part of the Pashtun people.
Taliban fighters move across the artificial Pakistan-Afghanistan
border, to borrow a Maoism, like fish through the sea. Osama bin Laden
is a hero in the region, and likely shelters there.

The US just increased its reward for bin Laden to $50 million and
plans to shower $750 million on the tribal region in an effort to buy
loyalty. Bush/Cheney & Co. do not understand that while they can rent
President Musharraf's government in Islamabad, many Pashtun value
personal honor far more than money, and cannot be bought. That is
likely why bin Laden has not yet been betrayed.

Any US attack on Pakistan would be a catastrophic mistake. First, air
and ground assaults will succeed only in widening the anti-US war and
merging it with Afghanistan's resistance to western occupation. US
forces are already too over-stretched to get involved in yet another
little war.

Second, Pakistan's army officers who refuse to be bought may resist a
US attack on their homeland, and overthrow the man who allowed it,
Gen. Musharraf. A US attack would sharply raise the threat of anti-US
extremists seizing control of strategic Pakistan and marginalize those
seeking return to democratic government.

Third, a US attack on the tribal areas could re-ignite the old
irredentist movement to reunite Pashtun parts of Pakistan and
Afghanistan into an independent state, "Pashtunistan." That could
begin unraveling fragile Pakistan, leaving its nuclear arsenal up for
grabs, and India tempted to intervene.

The US military has grown used to attacking small, weak nations like
Grenada, Panama, and Iraq. Pakistan, with 163 million people, and a
poorly equipped but very tough 550,000-man army, will offer no easy
victories. Those Bush Administration officials who foolishly advocate
attacking Pakistan are playing with fire.

Eric Margolis, contributing foreign editor for Sun National Media
Canada, is the author of War at the Top of the World. Visit his



To subscribe to this group, send an email to:


Need some good karma? Appreciate the service?
Please consider donating to WVNS today.
Email for instructions.

To leave this list, send an email to:

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:

(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

No comments: